Prosecution history in claim interpretation at the EPO

​
Darren Smyth
​
June 10, 2026

Agathon AG v Intercom SRL, Knarr Vertriebs GmbH

Milan Local Division Decision of 5 May 20261

A recurring question at the UPC is the degree, if any, to which prosecution history can be relevant to the interpretation of claim scope.  Prosecution history is not among the means of claim interpretation enumerated in the leading Court of Appeal decisions on the topic (10x Genomics v Nanostring,2 Amgen v Sanofi,3 Meril v Edwards4) and first instance decisions have adopted various approaches in deciding whether the prosecution history should be consulted at all, and if so what weight should be attached to it. However, the Court of Appeal has indicated that applicant assertions during the grant proceedings can be seen as in indication of the view of the person skilled in the art at the filing date (Alexion v Amgen,5 confirmed in Philips v Belkin6)

This case related to alleged infringement of EP2363263, relating to a tool for injection moulding.  A key issue was the interpretation of feature 1.9 of claim 1 “the second rolling body row (16) abuts an encircling edge (18) concluding the circularly cylindrical surface (17) of the bolt (8)”, and in particular the term “abuts”.  During prosecution before the EPO the patentee had argued that it was essential that the second rolling body row abuts the edge, and the defendants argued that the claim interpretation being argued by the claimant before the UPC was inconsistent with this position.

The LD Milan, referring to the Court of Appeal caselaw, stated “Although statements made by the patent proprietor during examination proceedings before the EPO are not binding, they may nevertheless provide further guidance on interpretation as they reflect the possible opinion of the person skilled in the art.”  While the court primarily interpreted feature 1.9 on the basis of the description of the patent, construing it in the narrower manner contended for by the defendants and rejecting the broader interpretation advanced by the patentee, the prosecution statement was considered to “further confirm the correctness of the interpretation hereby adopted by the Court”.

Ultimately, the patent was found valid in an amended form according to Auxiliary Request 1 submitted in the proceedings, but not infringed by the defendants’ products.

The “indication of the view of the person skilled in the art” is a rather low weight of value to be attached to statements during the grant proceedings, and it seems unlikely that prosecution history will be decisive in UPC cases.

‍

[1] https://www.unifiedpatentcourt.org/en/node/183254

[2] https://www.unifiedpatentcourt.org/en/node/576

[3] https://www.unifiedpatentcourt.org/en/node/159788

[4] https://www.unifiedpatentcourt.org/en/node/159797

[5] https://www.unifiedpatentcourt.org/en/node/1366

[6] https://www.unifiedpatentcourt.org/en/node/149310

‍

Recent Case Reports

Qualified electronic signatures not necessary at the UPC after all
17 November 2026
The UPC Court of Appeal confirmed that a scanned handwritten signature satisfies R. 4.1 RoP, and that a qualified or advanced electronic signature is not required. It also upheld the Brussels Local Division's decision to keep Dutch as the language of proceedings, as all parties are Flemish-based and the claimant is a small enterprise.
Milan Local Division: formal and sequential evaluation of infringement notice under FRAND
17 November 2026
The Milan Local Division held that an SEP holder with a dominant position must, before commencing an action seeking an injunction, identify the asserted patent and explain how it is allegedly infringed sufficiently early to permit a genuine response. Notice given on the filing date, could not cure the omission, and this was not altered by the fact the injunction request was conditional.
Invalidity of juicer patent upheld on appeal
03 November 2026
The Court of Appeal upheld the invalidity of Hurom’s juicer patent for lack of inventive step, while clarifying the admissibility requirements for patent amendments and the use of the unamended description when construing amended claims. It also confirmed the UPC’s jurisdiction over infringement in Poland despite Poland not being a UPCA Contracting Member State, but found that Hurom had failed to establish infringement under Polish law.