Paris Local Division Revokes another DexCom Patent

​
Darren Smyth
​
January 22, 2025

DexCom, Inc. v Abbott Laboratories and 13 other Abbott entities UPC_CFI_395/2023

Decision of 11 December (ORD_63909/2024[1])

The second decision on the merits from the UPC came from the Paris Local Division and revoked DexCom's patent EP3435866 asserted against Abbott.[2] This decision is a similar case with a similar outcome.

DexCom asserted its patent EP3831282 against a number of Abbott entities, who counterclaimed for revocation of the patent.

An added matter attack raised for the first time in the rejoinder was deemed late filed and inadmissible. The Court only considered the sole ground raised in the original counterclaim, namely lack of inventive step. On this ground, the Court indeed found that the claims did not involve an inventive step when considered in view of "Valdes" combined with "Goodnow", prior art documents cited in the counterclaim.

Three auxiliary requests presented by DexCom were considered to involve added matter.

Accordingly, the Court ordered the revocation of the patent.

In view of the finding on validity, infringement was not considered.


[1] https://www.unified-patent-court.org/en/node/1319

[2] Reported here: https://eip.com/uk/latest/article/paris_local_division_revokes_dexcom_patent/

Recent Case Reports

Qualified electronic signatures not necessary at the UPC after all
17 November 2026
The UPC Court of Appeal confirmed that a scanned handwritten signature satisfies R. 4.1 RoP, and that a qualified or advanced electronic signature is not required. It also upheld the Brussels Local Division's decision to keep Dutch as the language of proceedings, as all parties are Flemish-based and the claimant is a small enterprise.
Milan Local Division: formal and sequential evaluation of infringement notice under FRAND
17 November 2026
The Milan Local Division held that an SEP holder with a dominant position must, before commencing an action seeking an injunction, identify the asserted patent and explain how it is allegedly infringed sufficiently early to permit a genuine response. Notice given on the filing date, could not cure the omission, and this was not altered by the fact the injunction request was conditional.
Invalidity of juicer patent upheld on appeal
03 November 2026
The Court of Appeal upheld the invalidity of Hurom’s juicer patent for lack of inventive step, while clarifying the admissibility requirements for patent amendments and the use of the unamended description when construing amended claims. It also confirmed the UPC’s jurisdiction over infringement in Poland despite Poland not being a UPCA Contracting Member State, but found that Hurom had failed to establish infringement under Polish law.