Darren Smyth explores the final decision from a UK Community Design Court which clarifies how to interpret a registered design

Darren Smyth
20 March 2021
Tags
Elements

The decision in the Rothy’s Inc vs Giesswein Walkwaren AG [2020] case was the last judgment handed down by a UK court acting as a Community Design Court. EIP Partner Darren Smyth explores the judgment, which demonstrates how to interpret a registered design, in the Journal of Intellectual Property Law & Practice.

Darren Smyth writes: “David Stone, sitting as a Deputy High Court Judge, clarified fundamental concepts in European design law, including how a registered design is to be interpreted from the images in the registration, and the determination in validity and infringement of whether a design produces a different overall impression on the informed user.”

The full article can be viewed here, alternatively the author’s take is available here.

Related articles

EIP Recognised in The Times Best Law Firms 2026
03 December 2025
EIP is proud to be featured in The Times Best Law Firms 2026, a prestigious list based on peer recommendations across the legal industry. This recognition highlights EIP’s commitment to technical excellence, client-focused service, and innovative IP strategies. From high-value patent litigation to strategic portfolio management, EIP continues to deliver results that matter for clients in technology, life sciences, and engineering. This accolade reinforces our position as a trusted leader in intellectual property law.
EIP Launches Tech & AI Function to Drive Innovation and Client Excellence
06 November 2025
When it comes to technology, EIP has always been ahead of the curve; we are proud to announce the evolution of our IT department into a dedicated Tech & AI function, marking a bold step towards...
EIP shortlisted for The British Legal Awards 2025
26 September 2025
We are proud to share that we've been shortlisted for The British Legal Awards 2025 in the newly introduced category: ‘IP Team of the Year'! A special shout-out to our fantastic Litigation team,...